Tres leches cake was something that I heard of many years ago, but up until recently, I had never tried. I’m not really sure why since I have always thought to myself that I needed to try it one of these days. Cake soaked in sweet milk and topped with whipped cream? Excuse me, but I should have jumped on that the second I heard about it.
But no. Years went by and I never tried it until now when I decided to finally just make one myself. Let me tell you, it was worth the wait! Creamy, soft, sweet, and delicious. Oh yes, you want to make this cake. While it takes some time, it is very easy to do and your patience will be rewarded.
How to make tres leches cake
First, cream a stick of softened butter. Don’t rush this step. Cream the butter until it is light, smooth, and fluffy. It should resemble cream cheese frosting more than whipped butter.
Once the butter is creamed, add eggs and vanilla until thoroughly combined. To that, you will then add the dry ingredients: cake flour, baking soda, and salt. Once the ingredients are combined, keep the mixer going for a few more minutes to beat some air into your batter. This will give you a fluffier cake.
Look at that fluffy batter. It’s the kind of batter that you can’t wait to lick off the beater; or is that just me? Pour the batter into a prepared 9×13 pan and bake at 350 degrees for 20-25 minutes. I use baking cooking spray, but you can use your preferred method to grease your pan.
When the cake is finished it should look like cornbread and a toothpick inserted inside will be clean. Take the cake out and allow it to cool on the counter for an hour or so.
Once cooled, poke holes in it with a skewer, chopstick, whatever you have on hand to make good sized holes. You want them to be big enough to soak up all of the tres leches goodness.
Have you been wondering where the milk is in this recipe? Well, wonder no more. Tres leches is three milks in Spanish and this when we get to those three milks. We are going to use evaporated milk, sweetened condensed milk, and Promised Land Homogenized Milk.
Why Promised Land? Because Promised Land gets their milk from Jersey cows (from the British Isle of Jersey, not New Jersey) and extraordinary flavor comes from extraordinary cows. Milk from Jersey cows is richer, creamier, and naturally higher in protein and calcium than ordinary milk which makes it the perfect choice for an extraordinary tres leches cake.
Mix the tres leches, or three milks together and pour it over your cake. Cover the cake put it in the refrigerator to soak up all of the tres leches for a minimum of 3-4 hours to overnight. Again, your patience will be rewarded.
When you’re ready to take the cake out of the refrigerator, make a batch of whipped cream for the frosting. Whip together heavy whipping cream, sugar, and vanilla until there are stiff peaks. I prefer my whipped cream on the thicker side, but you can whip yours to your desired consistency.
By now the cake has soaked up all of that delicious tres leches. Now top it with the whipped cream and spread it liberally. Once frosted, sprinkle a little cinnamon sugar on top, or just cinnamon if that’s your preference. Tres leches cake is best served cold, so cover and refrigerate until you are ready to serve.
Scroll to the end of this post for the full recipe.
If you would like to try Promised Land Natural Milk without added hormones, you can find it at Target. Not only is it on sale, you can also get $0.75 cash back on any 32 oz. bottle through the Ibotta app. Promised Land is available in four varieties: Homogenized Milk, Reduced Fat 2%, Midnight Chocolate, and Reduced Fat 2% Midnight Chocolate.